Tuesday, January 31, 2012

Class #3 - Media Images and Self Image

Class #3: America the Beautiful and Media Images –“America the Beautiful”

In class we watched the movie "America the Beautiful" where it spotlighted a 12 year old girl who becomes a model for fashions because she is 6 foot tall and can walk well in heels. They also dealt with the topic of plastic surgery for perfection, media messages, and self-esteem. What is the need of the US for physical perfection and what is the fall-out if you don't think you fit the desires of others? Where does happiness come from? Where does self-esteem come from? If you were providing counsel to your 6th grade or 7th grade younger sisters or cousins - what words of wisdom would you share?  Not many of us would go back to grades 6-12 just for fun.

 As food for thought - look at some of the comments for the YouTube video. What are your reactions?? What are your reactions to "The Photoshop Effect” and “The Photoshop Effect Part 2”

If there are songs or videos you think pertinent – please add them.

8 comments:

EA said...

I think that some many people think that if they can fix their every imperfection, then it results in an ability for them to receive the perfect opportunities in life. A lifestyle that is full of wealth, a perfect spouse, and true happiness. It is so sad that the world is so much about your outward looks and I wish it was so much more focused on the beauty that life is. Our views our whole lives are focused on being successful and being better then generations before us. I know that for myself especially, there are many things I have focused much of my energy on so that I would not be in the same position as my parents and be able to have a life where not only I can do what I want, but also help my parents out in return for sacrificing so much of their wants and needs to allow me to achieve my dreams. And ya, someday hopefully I can do that and it is nice and all but where does it all stem from? I believe it is because society has made us feel so imperfect or not good enough and created images in our head that the most beautiful people get what they want and those with money get what they want. I know thoughts can be convoluted as such but honestly, where is happiness at for any of those people. I feel that the only ones that find that happiness are the ones that care about their family and see it as beautiful, those famous people that would sacrifice everything for their family unit and not just themselves.

On another note, it drives me absolutely insane when I see guys like "butt" in the movie because I feel that there really are many guys in the world that are like that, and I think quite a bit of blame should be on his type because so many men that are like that are the ones that have money, the cars, etc and it is sometimes portrayed women want that prominent status, to be able to get what they want so they are willing to become arm candy for their so called "man". I feel that society just wants things to be easy and if you can pay for beauty that is an easy way to get the so called "things you want". The one thing that cracks me up is how, still almost everyone who is asked what do they want in life, the say "happiness". Well if they have done all this to their bodies and are so beautiful, why do they still answer this way. They definitely attract lots of attention, which I feel also stems from the fact that they are not happy. One of the reasons you never hear about people being happy and seeing life as beautiful is because these people are the ones in this world that do not need attention (such as camera time). They are content and have absolved themselves of life's problems by embracing what they have and understanding what things in life that truly matter. By resolving these problems created by society, they can love all the small things and truly can be happy. I believe happiness is being content with your life in all aspects. (This last part is what I would share with a teenager)

Anonymous said...

As disgusting and ridiculous as the information in the film and the YouTube videos may be, the truth is that we are all to blame for it. What were magazines like before Photoshop evolved? Years ago, what did 12 year-old girls dream of being? I'm sure they didn't dream of being models, of having flawless skin, or of getting breast implants for their birthdays. Girls that age should not be concerned with things like that. I admit, when I was that age, I didn't have flawless skin and was jealous of those that did. I had to write this down to figure out, but at the age of 12, I was in sixth grade. Sixth grade. At my school, that was still considered elementary school. I remember learning how to classify clouds that year and thinking that it was cool. I also remember sneaking notes to each other between classes. Those are the types of memories that should be made during that age. I cannot even fathom what it would be like at that age to be a highly sought-after model--booking shows and flying from one city to another from one day to the next. It is the age that we live in, though. We all desire perfection and seek approval of others in one way or another.

The thing that disgusted me the most about the girl's story was that her mom seemed to be forcing that lifestyle upon her. She seemed worried with the financial benefits and of her daughter being able to live the life she wanted for herself, but didn't seem to mind the fact that her daughter was attending parties that included topless women and who knows what other kinds of activities. In a way, it reminded me of the show "Toddlers and Tiaras". I have never watched the show--I refuse to. I have seen previews for it, though. Those little girls (4 years old? 5?) backtalk their mothers and disrespect them as would be normal for teenagers--not for a child their age. I cannot imagine the ramifications that being brought up in that type of scene that places so much importance on their appearances will have on their self-esteems as they grow up. Our obsessions with reality TV shows such as these only fuel the problem, in my opinion.

The one thing that I learned from watching the film that I was not aware of beforehand was that "plastic surgeons" do not have to be board-certified in order to perform surgeries. Included in the show was a "plastic surgeon" (I forget his name) that actually has a show on E! in which he performs plastic surgeries! I don't even know where to start. Obviously, E! must be aware of the fact that he is not a board-certified plastic surgeon, but yet they cast him in a show performing numerous surgeries. Maybe they ignore that fact because he is good-looking, which means the women will watch. Maybe they ignore the fact because his personality will pull in viewers. Whatever the reason, I find it pathetic.

I agree with Caitie--it is truly frightening to think about raising a child in this world today. Thinking back to challenges my friends and I each faced in high school, I cannot help but hope that my children never have to face the same, although they inevitably will. Hopefully by then I will have some sound advice for them, like my mother did for me. Whether or not they will be wise enough at the time to accept my advice will be another issue on its own.

JS said...

The movie “America the Beautiful” opened my eyes to just how much the media controls the lives of individuals. Not only do they have an effect on the whole population, but their main target audience is young girls. This is frightening to me as I feel that this is the most vulnerable population. The media causes us to strive for “perfection” when what it truly forces is to strive for is only obtained through photoshop or a size 2 pair of jeans.

I really loved the Dove Beauty youtube video. It shows just how much work goes into making a celebrity look the way they do. Seeing the progression was very interesting. The other youtube video taught me something I did not know. I was not aware that celebrities hire people to photoshop every picture taken of them before it is released. This shows just how bad things have become and how much they have changed. It reminded me of a photo that I found on the internet, which can be found at this link:
http://cdn.blisstree.com/files/2012/01/when-did-this-become-hotter-than-this.jpg

There is also an interesting blog that shows the difference between the ads from the past and the ads that we discussed in class this week.
http://iamfabulicious.blogspot.com/2011/11/perception-of-beauty-how-times-change.html

I believe we are beyond the point of reversing this problem. This was the topic of the first youtube video we watched. She addressed the point that there really is no way to reverse or ban photoshopping images in the media. I also do not believe that putting a disclaimer in the corner of a picture will do much to prevent this problem.

It was interesting to see Gerren’s progression once she entered the fashion world. When she was first introduced she seemed to have all of the confidence in the world. However, as she continued to be around the modeling and fashion world, she lost that confidence and was even convinced that she was ugly. This further proves what I have come to believe: the main thing that is lost through fashion and media is self esteem, and it is self esteem that is most important in helping teens and young adults develop.

Another interesting thing about Gerren’s story is her mother. I was shocked to find out that she was only 12 years old in the opening scene. She was modeling in a small bikini and was surrounded by alcohol. It is ironic that her mom would allow her to experience and participate in these things at such a young age but later would not allow Gerren to wear a bra to school when she wanted.

I felt a lot of sympathy for the mother that lost a child to an eating disorder. The pain she must have felt for trying and not being able to help her daughter is unimaginable. This movie made me very scared to become a mother. The mother that lost a child held so much sadness and guilt that I hope I never have to feel for my child. It was interesting how different the mothers in the movie were portrayed. On one hand you had a mother that just wanted her daughter to outlive her. On the other hand, they showed a mother that was encouraging her daughter to get liposuction from her “love handles” in order to increase her chances of becoming a model.
Both Gerren’s mom and the mother suggesting plastic surgery for her daughter reminds me of the mothers featured in the shows known as “Toddlers and Tiaras” and “Dance Moms”. I feel like these mothers are pushing their daughters so hard to excel in order for them to live vicariously through them. I am so proud of my mom in the fact that she allowed my brother, sister, and I to participate in things that interested us. She always encouraged us to do our best at what we did and taught us that we should not quit when things got hard. However, she never pushed us past our breaking point or forced us to participate in activities that we did not want to.

Overall I enjoyed “America the Beautiful”. It further made me aware of the issues that are going on in our culture today.

Anonymous said...

As someone said earlier, “America the Beautiful” really opened my eyes as well. Personally I have seen many of my friends, members of my family struggle with some of the issues that were portrayed in this film and in the film we watched last week.
Growing up I was taller and heavier than most of the females in my class which made me uncomfortable but never was I more uncomfortable than I was at dance class. My best friend, who had been my friend since we were 5 years old, was in my class and was very similar in height and weight to me. She was also very unhappy with her appearance. When we were 11 years old, my friend started to lose a lot of weight and soon it became apparent that she was anorexic. When I would ask her how she lost the weight, the only answer I would ever get is that she wanted to beautiful and the only way she could do it was to lose weight. Eventually, teachers became concerned and talked to her mother who placed her in counseling. She was in counseling for a year until she learned how to eat again and started to gain weight.
Seeing the struggle she went through has helped me become comfortable with myself over the years but it has been difficult. Why? Why did we think that being thin would make us beautiful? I truly believe that peer pressure was what did it for me. At the age of 11, we felt like we were so different and just wanted to be "normal" for once. Those thoughts faded as we got older but even today there is still the pressure to be thin from society. The other day I had a friend tell me she was counting calories and sent me a link to a blog called "Thinspiration." She said this blog was her motivation to lose weight. I clicked the link and was horrified. Most of the pictures were of women that were too thin. I started to say something but then she said "I wish I was anorexic but I couldn't do it." WHAT? I quickly tried to talk her out of it, keeping in mind what I had seen my friend go through years before. But how can a young woman be so unhappy with her appearance to wish she was anorexic? Here is the link to the blog in case anyone would like to see what I’m talking about. http://thinspiration-pictures.blogspot.com/. Note that the top of the page says that they are “pictures of real girls, models, and celebrities.” The videos on YouTube about Photoshop gave me a whole new perspective on this.
As someone previously mentioned, people that have a lot of money to pay for surgeries to correct their so called imperfections often say that what they want most in life is happiness, and the women with these rich men are really just “arm candy.” I have a family member who has been dating a millionaire for 8 years. Before she met him, she was 5’8” and weighed about 150 pounds and she was happy. When she first started dating him, he began telling her that her teeth were too crooked and that she was too fat and needed to start working out. She had dental work done, got veneers to make him happy, and started eating almost nothing and doing insane workouts until she lost weight. Currently, she is 5’8” and 110 pounds and he tells her she is too skinny. She is so unhappy with her life after being with him for so long that she has become an alcoholic. Yet this is what society tells us…be thin and you will be happy, be rich and you will be happy, be famous and you will love your life. My friend was so obsessed with being thin that it cost her her health and she was not happy. My family member has become thin and has a rich and famous boyfriend but she isn’t happy. Her boyfriend is rich and famous, but he has no family and he isn’t happy. So who are these people that are rich, famous, thin and happy? I’ve yet to find one. Why can’t we all just be who we are and be happy with ourselves no matter how rich or famous, or what shape or size we are? Why does society tell us that we have to be perfect? Because in the end, we are all beautiful in our own way no matter what we look like, dress like, or how much money we have.

LA said...

It seems like Americans now worry more about meeting an unattainable level of perfection and living up to the standards that the media creates, rather than seeking what truly makes them happy in life. So many people have transformed the idea of "The American Dream" into a nightmare because of a desire to reach the unattainable. There's a skewed impression that success is measured by appearance rather than true accomplishments, and as a result we have created a cycle of low self-esteem. So many people have the mentality that they can never measure up; that is because compared to the digitally altered "images perfection" on display in the media, it is physically impossible. I came across a picture of what Barbie would look like if she were 'life size' http://www.cbsnews.com/8301-504763_162-20055694-10391704.html and it is really disgusting how unrealistic it is. That's just one simple example of a very common toy that millions of American girls grow up with, and it's a terrible representation of the anatomy of a real person. Children are exposed to this fabricated image of reality via the media so early in life; it’s probably really hard for them to fathom what life would be like without an obsession with the media would be. In the video I thought it was really sad to watch them interview the girl that kept saying she thought she was ugly, but she didn't know why. She just insisted that she was ugly. No one had ever told her she was ugly, she just created that idea based on what she saw on TV and formed an idea of what she thinks beauty is supposed to be. I think it is really scary how negatively influential the media is right now on people and my advice to a young girl would be that not everything seen or heard in the media can be taken seriously. You cannot let the media influence who you can or cannot be--although it may appear that their main concern is not to help you make your life more glamorous, it's really only to make money.
I thought the “Photoshop effect” was really eye opening. I knew that basically every image that makes the cover of a magazine and a lot of ads are edited or enhanced in some way, but I never realized to what extent they were altered. It’s really somewhat strange to think that every image of a person in a magazine is not really a true depiction of that person; it’s really a bizarre thought. What’s the point of photographing people if that’s not what they look like in real life? I was surprised to hear that companies are starting to demand that every image be altered in some way before they will be printed. It’s scary to imagine what this trend will lead to in the future, because it doesn’t seem like there are going to be any changes made anytime soon.

Anonymous said...

My initial reaction to the videos in class was that I felt so mislead by the media and images that I see every day. The YouTube videos were very informative, because even though I know that images in magazines were photoshopped, I did not know to what extent alterations could be made. It is amazing and extremely frustrating that pictures can be so distorted. A person’s size can be completely changed with the click of a button. Women can be made to look flawless. All of this is done just to sell a product; but, instead it severely weakens self-esteem and sets unrealistic standards for society. I can say that I have definitely fallen victim to some of these false advertisements. Looking at an ad for makeup, I am drawn in by how perfect the model’s skin looks. I throw away all common sense and reasonable thought and instead wonder if that product could do the same for me. After purchasing the product and trying it, I am disappointed by the results and let myself believe that it is because of a flaw in me. While I know that images are distorted by retouching, it is very easy to be pulled in by the images and believe that this level of perfection is attainable, just by buying the product. This same scenario probably happens on a daily basis. It is quite disturbing what the media has done to shape our society’s view of beauty.

"America the Beautiful" touched on many important issues in beauty, self-esteem, and the media. It was very interesting to see the progression of the young model and how she started off her modeling career feeling confident and beautiful and it quickly changes. I feel that Gerren did not have an adequate role model to help her understand what is beautiful and to help build her self-esteem instead of her ego. I was honestly very shocked that a mother would allow her daughter to be exposed to an environment like the modeling industry at such a young age. I feel that the message she was sending her daughter was not positive and was setting her up for failure in the future. In my opinion, Gerren would have benefited from being at school and around kids her own age, instead of around 20-something models. One of the most interesting points of the movie, to me, was when Gerren was crying on camera because she wanted to wear a bra and makeup to school. Her mother basically told her that she did not want her at school dressed in clothing that may not be appropriate for her age and wearing makeup. It was clear that this was very confusing for Gerren because she had been liked in the modeling world for the way she looked. She would wear makeup and clothing which I felt was not appropriate for a 12-year-old, but in the modeling setting this got her attention and people thought that she was beautiful. Her mother was now telling her she couldn’t wear the things that had made her seem beautiful as a model. This would be a very difficult thing to understand for someone her age.

Unfortunately, society has unrealistic expectations of beauty. A lot of this seems to be propagated by the media. Like the women in “The Photoshop Effect” said, it wouldn’t be realistic to ban retouching or photoshop, but I think that a good start would be to put messages to the consumers that remind them that photos have been enhanced. Some people may not be aware of this fact, or others (like me) need a little reminder of this fact. I also think that it is important to discuss issues like beauty, happiness, self-esteem, self-worth with children at a young age and instill positive attitudes. Parents should try to set good examples for their children by avoiding self-deprecating behavior (as the mother that lost her child to bulimia talked about). I also think that it is important to help people understand at an early age that quick fixes like cosmetic surgery or weight loss pills will not provide true happiness. It seems that happiness that comes from others (or society) telling you that you are beautiful may only be temporary. Happiness has to come from within.

CM said...

I think the most important step to take towards achieving a less judgmental society is education. Documentaries like “America the Beautiful” help to educate the public about oppressive forces impacting our society. By exposing the inner workings of the fashion industry, including the manipulation of pictures via photoshop, this documentary was successful in examining how pervasive beauty standards are in society. I agree with the earlier posts that Gerren’s story, in particular, was very surprising and eye opening. It is tragic that a 12 year old girl was exposed to so much ridicule about her appearance at such a young age. Her mother was clearly living vicariously through Gerren and should have been protecting her instead of exploiting her. Gerren’s self-esteem plummeted after multiple rejections from modeling agencies and designers, and a once happy and spunky girl became self-loathing in a very short period of time.
If an individual’s appearance does not fit the desires of others then they can be ostracized by their peers and may develop a feeling of low self-worth. Being true to oneself is where I think happiness comes from. Adolescence can be a very difficult time in a person’s life because children and young adults are still trying to develop their identity. I wish I could think of something profound I would say to a middle-school aged person but I truly can’t. I would tell them to have self-respect, not be judgmental of others, and that most things get better as you get older. I just hope I will be a positive role model for anyone younger than me by staying true to standards I have set for myself.

JR said...

First off, here is the link of the news article I mentioned in class: http://articles.cnn.com/2011-07-28/world/airbrushed.advertisements.ban_1_julia-roberts-ad-image-tv-advertisement?_s=PM:WORLD., and here is the link to the image that was pulled in the UK: http://bit.ly/zVmdXT
I think one quote from this article really illustrates the viewpoint of many fashion photographs and the very people that promote this activity: “The company described the Roberts image – taken by celebrity photographer Mario Testino – as an ‘aspirational picture.’” If you look at the image, Julia Roberts, a 44 year old woman, has literally flawless skin. It is completely unrealistic for a woman even at 22, let alone 44, to not have a single wrinkle, pore, blemish, or freckle on her face. It is sad that this is what the media says we should aspire to look like. This is a completely unreal expectation, and ads like this continue to negatively alter a woman’s own self-esteem and make her think she has to achieve perfection to be beautiful. The video showed many women and girls holding themselves to these impossible expectations. It is so unfair for real women to compare themselves to celebrities and photo-shopped images, but sadly, this is a reality of our time. Unfortunately, some of the fall-outs were illustrated in the movie: self-deprecation, low self-esteem, which could potentially lead to eating disorders or death. With so many young adults, perfection is a necessity and is the only key to happiness.
A part of the movie that I thought was really alarming was the portrayal of Gerren’s relationship with her mother. I felt so sad for Gerren that her childhood was taken from her, after she entered a career in modeling at age 12, pushed by her ambitious mother (a former model). After she entered the modeling world, it seemed that she was unable to fit back into her middle school, and eventually she was taken out of school all-together and was homeschooled. By the end of the documentary, Gerren was telling the cameraman repeatedly that she thought she was ugly. It was really unsettling to me to watch this carefree girl become so self-loathing, after her modeling career disintegrated. Like we discussed in class, mothers have to be so careful on what they do, say, or encourage in front of their impressionable children. Gerren’s mother’s comments on her own weight were practically echoed by Gerren herself. It just really illustrated just how influential the thoughts of their loved ones are on their own actions.
If I had to give advice to a young girl in 6th or 7th grade, I would tell her to just remember to be herself, and to do what makes her happy. I think it is very important to educate young people from an early age that the pictures they see in magazines do not reflect real life. I think that it is probably impossible to not be exposed to these images, so that’s why I think it is so important to make sure to acknowledge the fact that the media tries to influence consumer behavior with unrealistic expectations.