Tuesday, March 20, 2012

Class #8 - Breast Cancer Issues

Class #8 - Breast Cancer Issues

Lisa Hayes shared her experiences with a diagnosis of breast cancer at a time when she was not insured.   She has a very positive attitude and turned her experience into an opportunity to serve other women through programming at the Gennesaret Free Clinic.  Do you have any additional questions for her?   Did you have any experience like with her daughters?   Many young women when diagnosed will try to shield her family from her fears – and not really talk about issues with their husband and make it seem like no big deal for her family.  Is this good or could it be a problem?  How has breast cancer affected your life?

9 comments:

Anonymous said...

Breast cancer is a topic that I am both interested in and terrified of. Both my maternal and paternal grandmothers, as well as three of my mother's four sisters, have been diagnosed with breast cancer. Luckily, all survived. Interestingly enough, with each family member, we have seen the age at diagnosis become younger and younger. Last year, my aunt was diagnosed with breast cancer at the age of 43--the youngest to be diagnosed yet. Something unique about her, compared to my other aunts that have had breast cancer, is that she has never had children. I spoke with her over the weekend about her cancer. She noticed a visible lump in her breast one day and consulted her doctor. After mammograms and a biopsy, she was diagnosed with triple negative breast cancer. She underwent a double mastectomy, then received chemotherapy and radiation. Her course of radiation was just recently completed, and her reconstructive surgery is set for the middle of next month. Being concerned with our strong family history, and after learning a bit about breast cancer in therapeutics, I have bombarded her with questions. I find it interesting that none of my relatives affected by breast cancer have tested positive for the HER2, BRCA1, or BRCA2 genes. My aunt explained to me her doctor's reasoning behind this: that some genetic mutation, so far undiscovered, was obviously occurring in our family. I would almost rather have learned that they had been found to be carriers of these genes--at least then, if I chose to, I could have testing done to see if I were also a carrier, and then decide where to go with that information from there. I find it a bit concerning that there are no defined guidelines as to how to approach the care of an individual with a strong family history such as mine. When discussing this with my doctor, she was unsure when my sisters and I should begin receiving mammograms. I just feel like this is a big gray area, which is surprising. Even though it seems that we are making great strides with breast cancer diagnosis and treatment, there still exist many questions to be answered.

Anonymous said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
Anonymous said...

Breast cancer has not affected my life personally, but I have discussed breast cancer with my mom as some of her friends have had breast cancer. I think that it is interesting that some women try to shield their family from their health issues. I can understand the feeling that they don’t want to disrupt their family’s lives, but I imagine that it may be hard not to talk about what they are going through with those that care about them most. I hope that for those women that choose not to share their feelings with their family, they have another person like a friend or counselor that they can speak with.

One thing that really struck me about our discussion on breast cancer was the average size of lumps found by a mammogram, by a clinician, or by a woman. It was surprising that the average lump of a woman that does monthly breast self exams is 21mm. This shows the importance of explaining to women that breast self exams should not be the only method for screening. By the time they notice a lump, the cancer may be quite large and advanced.

Also, I had never heard of inflammatory breast cancer and it was very interesting to learn that it is usually a more advanced form of breast cancer once diagnosed. I am curious if many women know about inflammatory breast cancer and the fact that it usually doesn’t present with a lump. Learning that there is a type of breast cancer that usually isn’t detected by a lump or by mammogram is very eye-opening and something that I will be sure to share with others. I read an article online about a woman that was breastfeeding and thought that she has mastitis because of a blocked duct, but was shocked when she went to the doctor and was diagnosed with inflammatory breast cancer. And as discussed in class, other women thought they had a bug bite and were given antibiotics. I think that because the emphasis is usually on the typical presentation of breast cancer, women don’t know that there is another type of breast cancer and may not be as quick to investigate unusual symptoms.

Anonymous said...

It is understandable that some people with a new diagnosis such as cancer would work to protect others from feeling a burden from their disease state, especially those with younger children. I can imagine would be particularly difficult to accept such a frightening diagnosis and I think that if I were in that scenario part of me would want to protect my family from being affected by my diagnosis, and I would want life to remain as normal as it possibly could be. Although I'm sure that many people do avoid exposing their families to their full emotions when experiencing a cancer diagnosis, it seems like this could be the source of many problems if they don't seek alternative support systems, especially because there are so many elements to a cancer diagnosis besides just the healthcare aspect. There is obviously a large financial aspect of a cancer diagnosis, and I never knew there were organizations in our community that helped pay for cancer treatments for individuals without insurance. Lisa mentioned that she attends appointments with some of the patients she interacts with and provides a support system for those patients, which reinforces the fact that a source of support is essential for people coping with a cancer diagnosis. Possibly individuals that have a fear of burdening a family member need more support form a non-family member or a friend that understands what they are experiencing and to help them find resources to help them either emotionally or financially. I think that this is an aspect of cancer care that I haven't considered yet and it's important to recognize the importance of supporting our patients in a manner other than just through drug therapy or physical interventions.

My paternal grandmother was a breast cancer survivor, but that is my only personal connection with breast cancer. She received her diagnosis when I was much younger so I wasn't very aware of how much of an impact that the diagnosis had on her life and the rest of my family. I'm glad we had the opportunity to hear Lisa's story because it is a popular topic when it comes to cancer, and I hadn't put a lot of thought into the topic of breast cancer outside of therapeutics and PDA lectures.

CM said...

Two of my great grandmothers had breast cancer and survived it. One of my great grandmothers had a double mastectomy to treat her breast cancer because her cancer was caught later in the disease progression. Her daughter, my maternal grandmother, was diagnosed with breast cancer around the age of 58. I was in the fifth grade when my grandmother was diagnosed. We didn’t talk about it much in my immediate family, but I think this is because her breast cancer was caught very early and was not aggressive. Additionally, my siblings and I were only 7, 10, and 12 years old at the time so my parents may have thought we would not understand all of the intricacies of treating and managing cancer. My grandmother had very good medical care and has been cancer free and in extremely good health for over 10 years now.
My family is very open about medical issues and I like this about us because I think having a sturdy support system within your family can help to cope with a disease or condition. It is not surprising to me that many women try to shield their family from their fears when diagnosed with cancer or another disease/condition. Women are often the caregivers in their family and feel that it is their responsibility to keep the family protected and shielded from her problems. I can understand not wanting to be alarmist or to frighten children when a parent has a new diagnosis of cancer; however, not discussing a person’s fears and anxieties can lead to more issues later on. I think women should be able to freely discuss their fears with their partner so that person can take some of the burden of a person with a new diagnosis. Partners and families are built-in support systems to help each other cope and manage a disease.

JS said...

I was very impressed with Lisa Hayes’s story about her experience with breast cancer. She did an excellent job at explaining what she went through as a patient and also as a wife and mother. I admire how she was able to use her experience to change the direction in which her life was headed. Having experienced the cancer process herself as an uninsured individual, she is able to help other women at the clinic receive the necessary screening and treatment in much the same way the little red door cancer agency was able to help her. I have been very fortunate in the fact that I have not had an immediate family member become diagnosed with cancer. I have not had to witness the struggles that families with a member suffering from cancer experience on a daily basis. I can picture my mother trying to shield us from what she is feeling and experiencing. I do not necessarily think this is a good thing, because she may be ultimately hiding something that may need attention. I also do not think it is good to withhold feelings during the healing process. I think it is good to discuss any anger or sadness that may coincide with such an extreme diagnosis at a young age.

JR said...

I really enjoyed being able to listen to Ms. Hayes share her story. I, in general, have enjoyed being able to listen to different guest speakers come in and share their experiences with us. In Therapeutics and PDA, it’s really easy to just think of the disease and not think of the person who has the disease. I really like that in this class, unlike all of our others, we get to hear the patient’s point of view, which has given me a whole new perspective on these disease states. I think this experience for us will help us on rotations, since we have already been able to hear a patient’s point of view first hand. I really admire Ms. Hayes’s approach to life after her diagnosis and treatment of breast cancer. It is so admirable that she felt moved to change her career path and help other women. I also really admire the way she seemed to handle the diagnosis. Every person handles a difficult diagnosis differently, but Ms. Hayes seemed to handle it really well, and turned it into an experience to help other women. Also, I agree with her approach on the disease and her family. I think it is extremely important for families to be involved in the treatment process and for families to be open with each other during times of illness. It is easy to shield yourself and just try to internalize your feelings, but I feel that the support system of a family is very important in recovery.

Anonymous said...

I have been blessed in that I have not had an immediate family member diagnosed with breast cancer. However, when I was in 5th grade one of my friends and role models was diagnosed with breast cancer and eventually lost her battle with it. Her name was Kelly and she was my dance instructor but everyone who knew her, loved her and immediately became family to her. I remember when I was younger knowing that something was wrong. She, like many women, wouldn't tell her husband or children about her diagnosis because she didn't want to be a burden. She kept it to herself for so long and started denying that it was as dangerous as it was; so the cancer grew and became very aggressive. Despite her doctor's encouragement to undergo chemotherapy, she delayed her chemotherapy because she didn't want to lose her hair and be a burden to her family. By the time she decided to go through with the chemo, it was too late and she passed away later that year while she was in her 40s. Her death took everyone by surprise and it was one of the first experiences I ever had in which someone I loved passed away.
Like Kelly, many women do not want to be a burden to their families so they don't tell them about their breast cancer. I do not think it is a good idea to keep something that important from your family. In difficult situations, such as this, you need the support of your family. In Kelly's case, she finally decided to go through with the chemo because of her family. If she had told her family sooner, it may have been possible for her to receive the treatment she needed earlier and she may have still been alive today.

EA said...

Honestly in my life, I have been very blessed to not know anyone close that has had breast cancer. Either that or they do a great job of not talking about it, but something tells me that is not the case :-) The only thing that I know about when it comes to family is that my great grandfather had breast cancer but not on wood, no one else in my family has been diagnosed with it. We have other problems such a melanoma and cardiovascular issues.

I believe that it is not a good thing to not talk to your family about being diagnosed with breast cancer and trying to hide things from them. They are there to be a support group and a condition such as breast cancer and its treatment with such unpleasant side effects, it is much easier to get through knowing that you have the support of loved ones. Your job being diagnosed with breast cancer is to fight the disease, not add to your stress with trying to hide things from your family.

Sorry I do not have much more on my mind when it comes to breast cancer because I have been blessed to not have to deal with such matters yet in my life and really do not have any close contact with anyone that has been diagnosed either. For now, until I am faced with challenge, I have dedicated my efforts to help raise money and awareness for breast cancer.