Friday, April 6, 2012

Discussion on Contraception and Panel on World Religions

This week we had a review and some cases for application on Hormonal Contraception. We also had a panel with some background from the viewpoint of Hindu, Buddhist, Jewish, and Christian-Catholic perspectives. Do you feel you understand some of the issue better? Have you researched your church's official stand on infertility? What if you find out in a few years that you cannot have children. Would you consider fertility treatments? It might help TI think through some of the issues prior to the discussion on Yuesday with Dr. Cariann Richey- Smith.

10 comments:

Anonymous said...

I was knowledgeable about the Catholic Church’s view on birth control; however I did not know how the views of Protestant and Anglican churches would vary. I thought they would be relatively similar to each other so I was shocked to see how different the various Protestant and Anglican churches’ stances on birth control were. I typed up a summary from Wikipedia discussing different Christian religions’ views:
• Anglicanism (The Church of England) states that the responsibility of deciding upon the number and frequency of children was to be determined by the husband and wife.
• The Evangelical Lutheran Church in America allows for contraception in the event the potential parents do not intend to care for a child.
• The Lutheran Churches of the Reformation say that birth control in all forms is sin; however, they allow for exceptional cases, for example, when the mother’s life is at risk.
• Other Lutheran churches of synods do not take a position at all regarding contraception.
• The United Methodist Church believes that each couple has the right and duty to “prayerfully and responsibility to control contraception according to their circumstances”.
• The Presbyterian Church supports full and equal access to contraceptive methods and even maintains that contraceptive services as a part of basic health care.
• The Mennonite Church has acknowledged the utility of modern methods of birth control while also teaching and encouraging love and acceptance of children.
• In Amish communities, all forms of artificial birth control and natural family planning are forbidden and condemned.
• The Hutterite Bretheren use contraception if it is recommended by a physician.
• The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints condemn artificial birth control and believe contraception is contrary to the teachings of the Church.

Note: information obtained from [http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Christian_views_on_contraception] and [http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Religious_views_on_birth_control]

CM said...

During the panel discussion of contraception and abortion from the viewpoint of Hindu, Buddhist, Jewish, and Christian-Catholic perspectives, I found it interesting to see how many similarities existed between the seemingly very different religions. Dr. Ramaswamy introduced the idea of how religious doctrine and cultural expectations can be the same in certain populations but not in all. Each of the religions discussed in the panel are thousands of years old. I would imagine that it can be very complicated for a follower of particular religion to make decisions in the modern world regarding controversial topics such as birth control, abortion, fertility treatments, etc. while wanting to stay in accordance with their faith.
If I found out in a few years that I could not conceive naturally I would consider fertility treatments. I’m curious to know how most American’s religious views and their respective church’s official stand on assisted reproduction would bear on their choice to undergo fertility treatments. I think it is important for healthcare practitioners to be mindful of external forces (such as religion or culture) that can impact a woman’s decision making process regarding birth control, abortion, assisted reproduction, etc. Respecting an individual’s faith background is very important in making recommendations tailored to fit that patient.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Religious_response_to_assisted_reproductive_technology

JHV said...

Thank you anonymous for nicely summarizing some of the Christian denominations and the official position of the group. As practitioners -- we need to be thinking in a multicultural and multi religious way about belief syste,s and cultures. There is a lot here to consider

EA said...

My core group of friends from High school are as follows: A Catholic, a Conervative/almost Orthodox)Jew, a Hindu, an atheist, and a Jehovah's witness. So through out my entire grade school experiences, I learned a lot of the preferences of each of the religions growing up. For me, this panel did not expose to me much of what I did not already know but there were definitely a few points brought up that I had not thought of before. I think it would have been really cool to here a Buddhist point of view because out of all the world religions this is the one I have been exposed to the least. I have taken several classes at Butler too that have addressed the differences between the world religions and I do find it very fascinating. I do think though for this panel to be the most informative, I think it would be extremely cool to have those bigger religious heads of each religion be able to come and talk about the view points from each of the religions, such as a priest, rabbi, etc.
Whether or not I would turn to fertility treatments could potentially be an option for maybe a child but after that I would much rather adopt children. I mean I feel like there is a reason for this infertility and there are many children out there that are parent less and I think the more I can help give those children in need of love the love they deserve the better I can help shape this world. I definitely do not think with infertility though I would want to use someone else's eggs or sperm. That just makes me feel like I am just making a baby to get adopted and that too me just seems wrong. For those who have ever other sexual preferences that dont have either eggs or sperm I think that is fine but for me I think that is taking it jsut to far and at that point I should definitely be considering adopting

Anonymous said...

I found it very interesting to hear takes on contraceptive issues from differing religious backgrounds. I had never really put much thought into the matter and had just assumed that all views would pretty much be the same. While I have a pretty good idea of where Catholicism stands on the issue, I have never really agreed with them. In my opinion, the views of the varying religions are outdated and not practical for enforcement in society today. Furthermore, I do not really think that this should be a solely religious issue. I think that people should form their own opinions on the matter, and not be instructed on what they should believe about these issues. However, I do not judge those that do choose to strictly follow the beliefs and practices of their religions--I feel that it is a personal issue. I know that Catholics believe in no forms of birth control--just natural methods. I feel like this is not practical, as society has changed dramatically from what it used to be, and that having birth control available is in the best interest of the population. It is hard for me to imagine a time when birth control was not available. One thing that I have never understood is medical professionals (pharmacists) allowing their own religious beliefs to interfere in their prescribing/dispensing practices. Even though everyone is entitled to their own opinions on the issue, they should not discriminate towards other opinions that differ from their own.

On the issue of fertility treatments, I honestly do not see anything wrong with them. If, one day, it becomes my only option for having children, I would not hesitate to consider each option carefully and choose the one that I felt most comfortable with. I definitely feel like I would feel much more comfortable with the more natural-ish options, such as using my egg and my husband's sperm, if that would be possible. In my opinion, fertility is a personal issue between a husband and wife. Whatever option they believe to be best for them when conceiving a child would be fine with me.

Anonymous said...

I tend to agree with the comment above. I think that as society changes, some beliefs may not be as practical or feasible any longer. For me, deciding on a manner of contraception or fertility treatments is not influenced by religion. However, I respect that for others their religion may play an important role. If I were unable to have children naturally, I would consider fertility treatments.

As a pharmacist, I would like to stay neutral and not let my own religious beliefs influence how I practice. I do not feel like it is my place to impose my own beliefs on others that may not feel the same.

JR said...

I thought last week’s class was very informative and helpful. I really enjoyed being able to review contraception with Dr. Papineau. I have a Women’s Health rotation in September at St. Vincent’s Women’s hospital, so this week’s lecture definitely helped me feel more prepared for the rotation.

I really enjoyed the panel with women from different religious backgrounds. I think it is important for us as health professionals to realize that some treatments that we find to be common may be considered radical and even outlawed in some religions. It is so easy to just think of the science behind these treatments, instead of focusing on the patient and the patient’s background. Contraception and fertility treatments are very sensitive subjects in many religions, so I was glad to have gotten the opportunity to discover the viewpoints of various religions. I strongly believe that we should be very mindful of patient’s differences in religion, and use this knowledge to help the patient choose treatment plans. I feel that this is something that can really help develop the relationship between the patient and health care professional. If the patient feels respected, they will be much more willing to trust us.

After listening to the panel, I do feel that I have a better understanding of these issues. I would definitely consider fertility treatments if I found that I could not have children. However, I do realize that this is my personal belief, and I would never, as a health care professional, try to pressure a patient into doing any sort of treatments.

Anonymous said...

I thought the panel discussion was very interesting, and I enjoyed hearing about other religious views of contraception. I haven't previously learned about the views of many other religions regarding these topics and I thought it was a good to hear the explanations of why certain practices are acceptable or unacceptable. I think it was a valuable discussion topic because this is something we will need to be considerate of as healthcare professionals, and I would imagine that patients would be very appreciative of someone that is understanding and considerate of religious beliefs when choosing appropriate contraceptive methods.

Regarding consideration of fertility treatments in the future, I think that I would definitely consider it. There are a lot of factors that play a role in that decision so I can see that it would be a very difficult decision for a couple to make especially when trying to respect religious beliefs of both individuals. I am interested to learn more about how different religions view the various infertility treatment options.

Anonymous said...

I really enjoyed the panel on world views of contraception. I used to have a close friend who was Muslim and she and I used to talk about differences between views of Christianity and Islam very often. It was great to hear perspectives from other religions as well and I do believe I will be able to treat patients better in the future having this knowledge.
Years from now if I should have fertility issues, I probably will consider fertility treatments if it is possible for me to do so. I am also a huge advocate for adoption so that would possibly be an alternative for me as well if I find myself in that kind of situation.

JS said...

I thought it was interesting to listen to the panel. I did not know much about the different religions discussed, and I was surprised to find out how similar many of the ideas on contraception and women's fertility are. My family is catholic so I was aware of many of their viewpoints on the subject matter. It was also nice to be able to review some of the different facts about the birth control options, as I believe it is something that I will need to be knowledgeable on as a female pharmacist.