Thursday, April 12, 2012

Week #13 Interviews and Infertility

Did you find the interview an interesting assignment - did you learn from it? Be honest.  How do you go about making an honest assessment of what a patient tells you that the Dr told the patient -- that is the situation we find ourselves in while in community practice.  It is kind of a sleepover gossip game.  It may lose in the translation.  Now added a few years to it (it happened > 20 years ago) and  you can see why getting a complete PMH is hard and may be biased.

***********************

Please provide comments or questions from the materials on Infertility as provided by Dr. Richey-Smith.   What questions remain in your mind?

·         Once again - this is an area where medicine and religion mix.  This is an area where you might be wise to investigate a little on the guidance from major church groups so you are prepared for questions that might arise.

·         Is this are area we should explore more next year - that is - the interface of religion and modern therapeutics?

5 comments:

Anonymous said...

The part of the interview project that I found most interesting was hearing of the other interviews. I enjoy hearing about others' experiences with healthcare, especially when they have had good experiences. It is not as rewarding to hear about bad experiences. The woman I interviewed had just recently gone through the medical treatments tied to her disease, so recalling exactly what she had been through was not difficult for her. If I had interviewed an older woman that had experienced her troubles years ago, I feel that I would have had a difficult time sorting through what was fact vs. fiction in her story. It is hard not to believe someone and sympathize with them when they tell you of hardships faced, even though they may tend to exaggerate them a bit.

I enjoyed hearing of Dr. Richey-Smith's story last class. If I had heard it last year, it still would have been interesting, but being that she is now "naturally" pregnant, it adds a lot more of excitement to it. Just like Janae's patient interview that she shared--it is always great to hear of amazing things happening to good-hearted people. Like I commented last time--while I do realize and respect that different religions have differing opinions on the matters surrounding contraception, to me, it comes down to the simple fact that a couple that is unable to conceive is desiring to do what they must do in order to become parents. I do not feel like what their practicing religion has to say on the matter should make a difference in their goals.

Anonymous said...

I thought that the interview assignment was a good reminder that when speaking with patients, we must operate with a little bit of skepticism that their responses are accurate. While, I am not saying that we should never trust what patients say, we should also avoid always believing what they say. I am also not suggesting that patients lie; but for those with a long list of medications or a long medical history, it is probably difficult to recall information accurately sometimes. Also, for those that are not in the healthcare field, they may not understand what the doctor is telling them and they may feel embarrassed to ask more questions to help them understand. As a result, information can get lost in translation.

The woman that I spoke with had some difficulty recalling some of the information that I asked her, such as what the doctor told her about hormone replacement. She also had trouble recalling medications that she had taken in the past. It is to be expected that patients won’t remember everything that the doctor tells them. I think that as pharmacists, we can be helpful in encouraging patients to ask questions if they don’t understand. Suggest that patients write down questions ahead of time so that they don’t get distracted during their exam and forget to ask something. My mom does this all the time, and she has influenced me to do it because I have often found that I forget all of the questions I wanted to ask the doctor when they walk in the room.

I found Dr. Richey-Smith’s story to be very interesting. I think it is incredible that women can go through so much and struggle with infertility for some time, only to get pregnant naturally later. I cannot say for sure what I would do if faced with the same situation, but I imagine that I would explore all options and weigh all of the risks and benefits. For me, religion would not play any part in my decision; however, I see the importance of considering religion for some. I am glad that we have talked some about differing religious views and their opinions on fertility treatment because for me, I think it would be easy to forget these issues since religion would not go into my own personal decision. I would be interested in hearing other stories of women that had to balance religious beliefs with infertility options and how their religion impacted their course of therapy.

EA said...

I honestly did not find the assignment interesting only because I have done it in the past. Yet, what I did find interesting was listening to everyone else’s stories. I love hearing emotional or heart felt stories, especially the ones that you can relate to and feel for the patient. I do feel that some of the information does get lost a bit in translation but I feel that the bigger problems occur with many doctors not giving their patients enough information. So many doctors are just “too busy” and do not take the time to increase patient autonomy, which I think would be huge for decreasing health care costs and decrease patient morbidity and mortality. I definitely believe that religion and medicine should be looked into more, but as I stated before I think it would be better to have those come whom are either professionally trained or extremely well versed in the theology of their respective religion

Anonymous said...

I thought it was interesting to hear everyone's stories they gathered from their interviews and it was a good way to hear about disease states we had not previously discussed in class. I'm not sure that I learned a lot about assessing information that patients received from their doctors from this assignment in particular, but I do think that it is a scenario that we will be exposed to a lot in community practice.

I found the topic of religion and therapeutics to be a really interesting topic. It's obviously a topic that doesn't get discussed anywhere else in our curriculum but it is valuable to be aware of. I thought it was nice to explore something a little off of our normal path and apply it to a therapeutics topic. It would have been interesting to see more people and representation of more religions on that panel.

JS said...

I thought it was very interesting to hear from Dr. Richey-Smith about her infertility experiences. My mother actually struggled with infertility for quite some time and it was interesting to get to hear both viewpoints as my parents ultimately chose to adopt.

While interviewing my mom, I learned of just how much of an emotional roller coaster the process can be I thought the interview was a very interesting assignment because I was able to learn more about my mom and how our family came to be.

I also believe it is important to focus on how different religions play into medicine. It can allow for better understanding of both patient and coworkers.