Thursday, January 19, 2012

Accounts to easily post to the Blog

you may need a google account or one of the others listed if you wish to follow the blog or post without verification of your identity

7 comments:

CM said...

I came across this website a few months ago and thought it might be interesting to discuss it in tomorrow's or the next week's class:
http://www.mybodygallery.com/index.html
The website allows women to upload pictures of themselves anonymously and asks them to enter in their height, weight, pant size, shirt size, and body type. The website says their aim is to "project and build a collection of photos that will help more women see themselves more clearly".

JS said...

There was a very interesting study that was conducted during WWII known as the Minnesota Starvation Experiment. It was conducted in order to document how patients acted when their bodies were starved and was completed with different ways of re-feeding in order to determine the best way to reintroduce food into the starved patients. It is really interesting to read about this study because it is very controversial and would not be allowed to be done today. Also these men displayed many of the signs and symptoms of eating disorder patients that we discussed today in class such as collecting recipes and allowing food to control their every thought. The article is from the Journal of Nutrition and is titled, "They Starved So That Others Be Better Fed: Remembering Ancel Keys and the Minnesota Experiment".
http://jn.nutrition.org/content/135/6/1347.full

KC said...

I was watching the news last night and saw something that goes along with our topic of eating disorders this week. Today on the Dr. Phil show there will be a young woman named Mercedes that is a 79 pound anorexic that binges on beer and then purges. I'm a little confused about this though. Because she is binging and purging, I thought she would be considered bulemic but they keep calling her anorexic. Is this just because her only source of nutrients is beer and not food?

Here is the Dr. Phil website link describing this show that will be playing today: http://drphil.com/shows/show/1774

EA said...

As I started to share in class, many people do not think about exercise as being a case when it comes to an eating disorder but I feel that it is one of the most prevalent and easily seen problems. These people are always constantly at the gym, but one of the hardest things is to try to provide this person care. It is such a touchy topic and the people experiencing these problems believe that no one notices but when they are approached, they are truly like a deer in the headlights and then take off running. I really liked the point JVT brought up in class about guys seeing other guys and being jealous of their bodies and such. I never really thought about it that way but let me tell you all, it is totally true. Guys are constantly trying to perfect themselves and some even destroy their bodies to do so. It truly sucks the world is so much about image, but it really should be about health. I think it would be really cool that our race could adopt these philosophies and make the most healthy people the idols of our world. That you do not need all the muscles or to be as skinny as twig but rather you should be embraced for caring about yourself and keeping a well balanced lifestyle.

LA said...

I was a dancer for about 13 years and I saw my fair share of people dealing with eating disorders or suspected eating disorders. From my perspective, dancers are essentially taught that everyone needs to look the same and every movement must be in unison with the group etc., and there really is a great deal of pressure to achieve a level of “perfection” in that setting (and that was just at a beginner/intermediate level, I can only imagine how demanding a professional ballet school could be). That being said, it doesn’t surprise me that so many dancers/athletes, whose careers depends on their body image, suffer from eating disorders. In the video, I thought it was nice to see a professional ballet instructor being very supportive of his dancers by encouraging them to take time off and not sacrifice their health for the sake of dance. Maybe we just need more people in these careers need to adopt that way of thinking in attempts to minimize this trend. It’s pretty apparent that there is a link between eating disorders and the pressures of our society, and I think it’s going to be really interesting to look more closely at what role the media plays in those pressures.

Anonymous said...

Our discussion about the dancers in Butler’s ballet program reminded me of a friend of mine that was a dancer was told one day that she needed to lose nearly 20 pounds. I remember several of her friends and me looking at her and thinking that she did not have 20 pounds to lose, and it would be very unhealthy for her to do so. I know she felt tremendous pressure, despite many of her friends telling her that she was healthy and should not lose that much weight.

Watching the video also made me think of this, and really feel concerned for people whose success or careers relied on maintaining a particular weight (and maybe often an unhealthy weight). For these people, not maintaining that weight may impact how they make a living and this can be a big motivator to use drastic measures to reach their goal.

While I knew previously eating disorders were a growing problem, I hadn’t really made the connection between eating disorders and how a person makes a living. The video and our discussion opened my eyes to this. It is disappointing that this kind of pressure is put on individuals. The emphasis should be on being healthy and maintaining a healthy weight, not trying to fit into a certain size.

Thankfully, my friend did not take drastic measures to lose weight; but, I wish that instead of just saying she needed to lose 20 pounds, one of her instructors would have taken more time to talk to her and offer assistance in eating healthy and maintaining a healthy weight.

JHV said...

Thanks you all for your comments - I am glad to see the connections you are making. This is an issue where it is hard to talk with patients even though you may recognize what is going on. Encourage healthy behaviors for your patients and when you become parents work with other parents for healthy approaches to body image. The primary treatment for these still remains psychotherapy with drug therapy a distant second.
For those w ho have posted here - you do not need to re-post a comment. I will put a new comment area for comments.